TELOSscope: The Telos Press Blog

The Cultural War between Athens and Jerusalem: The American Case

Luciano Pellicani ‘s “The Cultural War between Athens and Jerusalem: The American Case” appears in Telos 162 (Spring 2013). Read the full version online at the Telos Online website, or purchase a print copy of the issue in our store.

Despite what Harold Berman claimed, the writers of the American Constitution were not inspired by strong religious convictions. On the contrary, as typical men of the Enlightenment they were severe critics of Christianity, considering it an obscurantist and intolerant tradition in all its versions. Hence their cultural battle to achieve the institutionalization of what Thomas Jefferson called “the wall of separation between State and Church” that would guarantee the greatest religious freedom. A freedom that was periodically threatened by fundamentalist movements which, in the name of Jerusalem, sought—and still seek—to establish a confessional state governed by the truth revealed in the Bible whereas the founding fathers hoped that “what Athens was in miniature, America will be in magnitude.” It is not true that America was born modern and progressive, as Ernest Gellner has maintained. It became so through the cultural war between Athens and Jerusalem that began in the eighteenth century and is still in progress.

1 comment to The Cultural War between Athens and Jerusalem: The American Case

  • Richard Walters

    Really? You’re going to have to get rid of a lot of documentation to convince me. It seems to me they were wanting to be free to entertain their own thoughts about God – Not be mandated what to believe by the state. The way they describe God himself reflected that in much of the documents we find. I think your article is only partially right but mostly wrong.